Contractual control over how, where and when a cleaner works points toward employee status; a right for the cleaner to choose those matters, subject to reasonable direction from the hiring business, points toward independent contractor status. Neither feature decides classification alone: the Australian Taxation Office says the contract’s legal rights and obligations must be assessed as a whole, and its guidance, updated 17 December 2024, separately identifies work that is wholly or principally domestic for more than 30 hours per week as a circumstance in which superannuation must be paid even to an independent contractor deemed to be an employee for superannuation purposes. Figures checked 1 October 2026.
What does control over a cleaner’s hours and location actually show?
Control is an indicium, not a stand-alone verdict. The relevant question is what the agreement legally allows or requires.
| Contractual position | What it may point towards |
|---|---|
| The hiring business has a legal right to control how, where and when the cleaner works | Employee status |
| The cleaner can choose how, where and when the work is done, subject to reasonable direction from the hiring business | Independent contractor status |
For a cleaning agreement, examine whether the business has a legal right to prescribe hours and require the cleaner to work at specified locations. If the cleaner can make those choices while accepting reasonable direction, the control feature points towards contractor status.
Even extensive scheduling requirements do not settle the entire relationship by themselves. The ATO says no single indicium is determinative and that these features should not be applied as a checklist. It also explains that the old multifactorial test is no longer used, although the same indicia remain relevant when the assessment is confined to the legal rights and obligations agreed between the parties.
Does an “independent contractor” label decide the answer?
No. Under the ATO guidance, calling a cleaner an independent contractor neither determines nor is relevant to how the relationship is characterised.
The contract does not have to be entirely in writing. It may be:
- written;
- wholly oral; or
- a hybrid of written terms, oral terms and terms implied from conduct.
The ATO says the High Court judgments in CFMMEU v Personnel Contracting [2022] HCA 1 and ZG Operations v Jamsek [2022] HCA 2 clarify that the relationship consists of the legal rights and obligations arising from the contract.
That makes the operative terms more important than the document’s heading. A worker serving in the business as its representative points in a different direction from a contractor providing services to further their own business.
Can day-to-day scheduling override the written terms?
Not by itself. The ATO says conduct and work practices are irrelevant when analysing the indicia unless they are sufficient to vary the agreed contractual terms. A contract may also be varied based on the conduct of the business or worker.
If the written agreement and the cleaner’s actual roster tell different stories, the issue is whether that conduct varied the legal relationship. A repeated scheduling practice is not necessarily a variation; the ATO’s stated focus is whether it was sufficient to change the contractual terms.
What else should be read alongside control?
Compare the contract’s legal rights and obligations with the essential activities of the cleaning business. Other features can point in either direction:
| Feature | May point towards employee status | May point towards independent contractor status |
|---|---|---|
| Integration | The cleaner serves in the business and must act as its representative | The cleaner provides services and performs work to further their own business |
| Remuneration | Payment is for time worked, a price per item or activity, or a commission | The cleaner is generally engaged to achieve a specific result, is paid on completion and is often paid a fixed fee |
| Delegation | The cleaner must perform personally and cannot engage someone else | The contract gives a genuine, legally exercisable right to delegate or subcontract |
| Tools and equipment | The business provides all or most assets, or provides an allowance or reimbursement | The cleaner provides all or most assets without an allowance or reimbursement |
| Risk | The cleaner bears little or no risk, while the business bears commercial risk from injury or defects | The cleaner bears the commercial risk of injury or defects |
| Goodwill | The hiring business benefits from goodwill generated by the work | The cleaner’s own business benefits from that goodwill |
These features must be read together rather than treated as points in a scoring system. A particular payment method, tool arrangement or scheduling term does not override the rest of the relationship.
Does more than 30 hours per week automatically make a domestic cleaner an employee?
No. This is a superannuation rule rather than a general employee-classification shortcut.
| Stated superannuation circumstance | Application under the ATO guidance |
|---|---|
| The contract is wholly or principally for the worker’s labour | Superannuation must be paid in this circumstance even if the worker is an independent contractor deemed to be an employee for superannuation purposes |
| The work is wholly or principally domestic for more than 30 hours per week | The same superannuation consequence applies |
These circumstances do not replace the need to examine the working arrangement for tax and superannuation purposes generally.
Separately, the ATO lists apprentices, trainees, labourers and trades assistants as workers who are always treated as employees under its guidance.
What should a cleaning business or cleaner do next?
A practical review can be structured as follows:
- Identify the cleaning business’s essential activities.
- Gather the individual cleaner’s written, oral and implied contractual terms.
- Examine the legal right to control hours, location and working methods.
- Compare control with integration, payment, delegation, equipment, risk and goodwill.
- Check whether actual conduct was sufficient to vary the agreed terms.
- Record the reasons for the classification and reconsider it if the legal terms change.
The business is responsible for correctly classifying the worker for tax and superannuation purposes and may face penalties if that decision is incorrect. A business that believes a worker is an independent contractor may choose to pay superannuation to avoid liability for the superannuation guarantee charge.
This is general information, not financial or legal advice, and it does not determine insurance cover. Check the current ATO regulator page and the relevant policy’s PDS before relying on a classification or insurance term.
Sources
- Difference between employees and independent contractors | Australian Taxation Office — updated 17 December 2024. Figures checked 1 October 2026.
FAQ
Can a cleaner choose their own hours and still be an employee?
Choosing hours points towards independent contractor status, but it does not decide classification by itself. The ATO requires the whole relationship and its agreed legal rights and obligations to be considered; no single indicium is determinative.
Does a signed independent-contractor agreement settle the matter?
No. The label used in the contract is not determinative and is not relevant to characterisation. The legal rights and obligations matter, even where the agreement is partly oral or includes terms implied from conduct.
Can actual scheduling practices override the contract?
Only where the conduct is sufficient to vary the agreed contractual terms. A roster or repeated work practice is not automatically determinative merely because it is what happens in practice.
Does domestic cleaning for more than 30 hours per week automatically mean employee status?
No. It is one stated circumstance in which superannuation must be paid to an independent contractor deemed to be an employee for superannuation purposes. It is not a general classification test for every purpose.
Are apprentices, trainees, labourers and trades assistants always employees?
Under the ATO guidance discussed here, apprentices, trainees, labourers and trades assistants are always treated as employees.
Partner links. Using them costs you nothing extra and may earn us a commission.